Benny's Big Time Pizzeria Menu (Update 2025)
Benny's Big Time Pizzeria, located in Wilmington, NC, offers a diverse menu with Italian-inspired dishes. From their delicious house salads and antipasti to their mouth-watering pasta options like Spaghetti & Meatballs, and Rigatoni A la Vodka, Benny's ensures a flavorful experience. Their signature pizzas, ranging from traditional Margherita to unique options like Little Greenie and Meating of the Minds, are cooked in a wood-fired oven, providing a crispy crust and rich flavors. Customers rave about the attentive service, inviting atmosphere, and the variety of options catering to both vegetarians and meat lovers. With special discounts, like Margarita Mondays, Benny's Big Time Pizzeria is a must-try destination for a casual dining experience with friends and family.
BENNY'S SALADS, ANTIPASTI & FRIED STUFF
HOUSE SALAD
head lettuces, red onion, pickled peppers, smoky croutons, pecorino, house Italian vinaigrette
BENNY'S CAESAR
fried & raw brussels sprouts, romaine, pecorino, lemon, Little Green Dress, house-made crouton
CHARRED BRUSSEL SPROUTS
charred radicchio, dried cranberry, golden balsamic vinaigrette, pecorino
CHOPPED SALAD RED WEAPON RANCH
baby kale mix, romaine, provolone, salumi, chickpeas, olives, pecorino, Red Weapon ranch
BENNY'S CHICKEN PARM
stracciatella, hot honey, pickled peppers, sage
FRIED MOZZ
fried mozz fritters, w/ Marinara
SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
marinara, beef & pork meatballs, parmesan, oregano
RIGATONI A LA VODKA
house-made rigatoni, classic vodka sauce, burrata
BENNY'S PASTA
PIZZA (12-14 INCH WOOD FIRED)
CONSTRUCTION ZONE
Build your own pie. Keep it simple, if you get greedy your pizza will suffer.
GLUTEN FREE DETROIT STYLE PIZZA
Our gluten free DETROIT style pizza crust is amazing! Our standard comes with cheese and sauce but you can build your own pizza, just as you like it.
MARGHERITA
red sauce, basil, fior di latte (fancy mozz)
PINEAPPLE EXPRESS
pineapple jam, mozz, Calabrian & serrano chilies, speck & mint
LITTLE GREENIE
red sauce, garlic, pickled red onion, brussels sprouts, mixed greens, guindilla peppers, nutritional yeast, Calabrian chili
TONY PEPPERONI
red sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella, oregano
MEATING OF THE MINDS
Red sauce, mozz, 'nduja, pepperoni, sausage, pancetta, red onion, basil, Parm
SPACE JAM
red sauce, mozz, parm, taleggio, meatball crumble
PIZZA ALLA CARBONARA
white sauce, mozz, pecorino, garlic, red onion, chicken, pancetta, parsley, yolk
TALK'IN SHITAKE
Ricotta white sauce, sausage, shitake & cremini mushroom, fennel, mozz, parm, garlic, olive
KEVIN MCCALISTER
grayson taleggio, mozzarella, hot honey
DOOGIE HOWSER
mozz, parm, basil, sausage, soppressata
GRANDMA STYLE PAN PIZZA
Our classic Grandma style pan pizza isRectangular, crusty, classic sheet pan pizza goodness. Comes with red sauce, oregano, basil, mozzarella & parm (grandma pies will have a longer cook time)
SIDE PARM
SIDE RED WEAPON RANCH
SIDE HOT HONEY 2oz
BENNY'S HOT HONEY BEAR 6oz
Feeling like the little cup of Benny's Hot Honey is just never enough? Stock up with the Honey Bear!
SIDES
BENNY'S BIG TIMERS
BENNY'S HOT HONEY BEARS 6OZ
Feeling like the little cup of Benny's Hot Honey is just never enough? Stock up with the Honey Bear!
PIZZA PACKS - 3 TONY PEPPERONI'S
Why not have another slice? Or, keep a little Toni Pepp in the fridge in case of emergency. Either way, we got you covered.
PIZZA PACKS - 3 KEVIN McCALLISTER'S
Our wildly popular cheese pizza for adults - not adults only. The combination of the funky taleggio cheese and Benny's Hot Honey is now a little cheaper to hoard. Go for it.
LUNCH FOR 2
Margherita Pizza, Lg House Salad + 2 cans of soda